FC 25 Premier League TOTS Predictions: Who Will Make the Ultimate Squad?

As the Premier League season nears its dramatic conclusion, the spotlight begins to shift toward one of the most anticipated events in EA Sports FC 25 Ultimate Team—Team of the Season (TOTS). This annual promo is a fan-favorite, bringing upgraded cards for the best-performing players from each league. The Premier League TOTS is always the centerpiece of the campaign, and this year is no different. With surprises, standout performers, and shocking finishes, this season has delivered some incredible individual performances worth celebrating.

From Liverpool’s resurgence to Nottingham Forest’s Cinderella story and Chelsea’s breakout stars, we take a deep dive into the players most likely to feature in the Premier League TOTS for FC 25. These predictions are based on stats, impact, fan sentiment, and overall contribution to their team’s success. Let’s break it down player by player and see who could be in line for a massive Ultimate Team upgrade.

Matz Sels (Nottingham Forest) – 77 → 92 OVR

Golden Glove Contender from an Unexpected Hero

While big names like Alisson and David Raya often dominate TOTS discussions, Matz Sels has quietly built a compelling case for inclusion. Nottingham Forest’s shocking rise to the top four has largely been supported by Sels’ heroics between the sticks. The Belgian goalkeeper currently leads the Golden Glove race with 13 clean sheets—an outstanding achievement given the defensive frailties usually associated with Forest. He’s also made 89 saves, many of them match-defining.

Sels’ presence in the TOTS lineup would bring a refreshing underdog narrative to the promo, something fans often rally behind. A 92-rated TOTS card would be richly deserved and could turn out to be a hidden gem in Ultimate Team. With reflexes and positioning likely to be standout attributes, Sels would bring not just stats, but also story-driven excitement to the squad.

Trent Alexander-Arnold (Liverpool) – 86 → 95 OVR

Playmaker and Defender in One Complete Package

Despite ongoing transfer speculation linking him to Real Madrid, Trent Alexander-Arnold has remained laser-focused on his football, delivering arguably his most complete season yet. Known for his attacking brilliance, Trent has added a new layer to his game by improving defensively. With 2 goals and 6 assists, he’s continued to provide width and creativity, but it’s his positional awareness and maturity that stand out this season.

If this ends up being Trent’s final season in the Premier League, his TOTS card will serve as a fitting farewell. A 95-rated item packed with elite passing, pace, and defensive upgrades would make him a versatile option for any FUT squad. His inclusion feels inevitable given Liverpool’s dominance, and fans will no doubt welcome one last Premier League version of this generational talent.

Virgil van Dijk (Liverpool) – 89 → 98 OVR

Back to His Best and Leading by Example

When it comes to elite defending, few names carry more weight than Virgil van Dijk. This season, he’s returned to his imperious best, leading a Liverpool defense that has conceded just 27 goals in 30 matches. His leadership, aerial dominance, and calmness under pressure have been crucial in Liverpool’s title charge, proving that class is permanent.

Van Dijk is no stranger to TOTS squads, and his inclusion this year feels like a certainty. With his TOTY card already rated at 96, a 98-rated TOTS version would likely make him one of the most overpowered center-backs in FC 25. Expect elite defending, strength, and composure that will make him the cornerstone of many Weekend League backlines.

Gabriel (Arsenal) – 86 → 96 OVR

Arsenal’s Defensive Rock Gets His Recognition

Although Arsenal might miss out on the title, their defense has been among the league’s best. Gabriel Magalhães has been a major part of that success, forming a formidable partnership at the back and emerging as the standout figure in Mikel Arteta’s backline. Known for his aerial prowess and physicality, Gabriel has also chipped in with 3 goals, showcasing his threat on set pieces.

Despite suffering an end-of-season injury, Gabriel’s performances earlier in the campaign should be enough to earn him a place in TOTS. A 96-rated card with strong physical and defensive attributes would reflect his impact and could offer a left-footed option at CB—always a bonus for chemistry and squad building in FUT.

Antonee Robinson (Fulham) – 79 → 92 OVR

Fulham’s Assist King Flying Under the Radar

The left-back position in this year’s TOTS is hotly contested, but Antonee Robinson has built a strong case with his standout attacking numbers. The American full-back has notched 10 assists, an astonishing tally for a defender, and has been a key outlet for Fulham’s width and transitions. Defensively, Fulham has remained solid with only 40 goals conceded, which enhances his claim even further.

A 92-rated TOTS card for Robinson would offer a fresh, pacey, and creative option for Ultimate Team players. His unique profile as an offensive-minded LB from a non-top-six club would give FUT managers more flexibility, especially for those looking to build around MLS or USMNT links. This could be one of the more underrated cards in the promo.

Declan Rice (Arsenal) – 87 → 94 OVR

Midfield Dominance and Tactical Intelligence

Declan Rice has seamlessly adapted to life at Arsenal, becoming one of the most dependable midfielders in the Premier League. His ability to break up play, dictate tempo, and offer an outlet under pressure has been crucial in Arsenal’s top-two finish. With 2 goals and 5 assists, Rice has shown he’s more than just a destroyer—he’s a modern box-to-box midfielder.

A 94-rated TOTS card for Rice would provide a powerhouse midfield option for FUT players. His defensive stats would likely rival even icons and heroes, while his passing and physicality would make him a perfect CDM/CM hybrid. Expect him to dominate the midfield meta once again, as he did earlier in the cycle with his special cards.

Cole Palmer (Chelsea) – 85 → 97 OVR

Chelsea’s Shining Light in a Turbulent Season

It’s hard to ignore Cole Palmer when discussing TOTS contenders. Despite Chelsea’s rollercoaster campaign, Palmer has been their standout performer, tallying 14 goals and 7 assists in 29 appearances. His creativity, composure, and flair have been a breath of fresh air in an otherwise inconsistent squad.

A 97-rated TOTS Palmer would be a FUT manager’s dream—likely boasting high dribbling, vision, and passing stats. Given his previous TOTY inclusion and strong reputation among the community, his presence in this promo seems all but confirmed. Expect a meta-tier CAM or RW card capable of unlocking even the tightest defenses.

Ryan Gravenberch (Liverpool) – 78 → 94 OVR

The Silent Engine Behind Liverpool’s Midfield

Ryan Gravenberch may not get the headlines, but he’s been instrumental in Liverpool’s tactical system this season. After a slow start, the Dutchman has grown into his role, adding balance, structure, and control to the midfield. His off-the-ball movement, press resistance, and distribution have made him an essential part of Klopp’s starting XI.

A 94-rated TOTS card would celebrate his unique role—a deep-lying playmaker with flair and intelligence. Expect a tall, skillful midfielder with high stamina and technical stats, making him ideal for FUT managers looking for an elegant CDM or CM. He might not be flashy, but he’s the kind of card that glues elite squads together.

Mohamed Salah (Liverpool) – 89 → 98 OVR

The Undisputed Player of the Season

If there’s one player who’s guaranteed a TOTS spot, it’s Mohamed Salah. With 27 goals and 17 assists in just 30 appearances, the Egyptian has been nothing short of phenomenal. He’s not even a striker, yet he leads both goal and assist charts, continuing to redefine what it means to be a winger in the Premier League.

A 98-rated Salah TOTS card would likely rival his TOTY and past special items. With blistering pace, five-star skills (if upgraded), and top-tier finishing, he’ll be one of the most expensive and sought-after players in the game. Whether he stays at Liverpool or not, this card will be a mainstay in FUT squads throughout the summer.

Alexander Isak (Newcastle United) – 85 → 96 OVR

From Potential to Premier League Powerhouse

Alexander Isak has truly come into his own this season, scoring 20 goals in just 25 starts. His composure, dribbling, and clinical finishing have elevated him to one of the most feared strikers in the league. Newcastle may not secure a Champions League spot, but Isak’s performances speak for themselves.

His potential 96-rated TOTS card would bring a tall, agile striker with exceptional shooting and dribbling. FUT fans love cards like Isak—big frames, rapid pace, and silky movements. If he gets five-star skills or weak foot upgrades, he could be a serious Weekend League weapon.

Erling Haaland (Manchester City) – 91 → 97 OVR

A "Quiet" Season by His Standards – But Still Dominant

Erling Haaland might not have shattered records like last season, but with 21 goals, he’s still among the best. Critics calling this a “poor” season just prove how high the bar has been set for the Norwegian powerhouse. His physicality, positioning, and finishing remain elite, making him a constant threat.

A 97-rated TOTS Haaland would be pure chaos in Ultimate Team. Expect maxed-out shooting, monstrous strength, and possibly improved dribbling and passing. Despite City's relative disappointment this season, Haaland's personal numbers make him a lock for inclusion—and a nightmare for defenders in FUT.

Conclusion: A TOTS to Remember in FC 25?

The Premier League TOTS in FC 25 is shaping up to be one of the most exciting lineups in recent memory. This team has everything from high-flying wingers and goal machines to defensive rocks and breakout midfielders. Expect a mix of the expected—like Salah and Van Dijk—and the underdogs like Sels and Robinson, offering a well-rounded and FUT-meta-defining promo.

Who do you think deserves a spot in the FC 25 Premier League TOTS? Are there any snubs you’d include? Let us know in the comments—and don’t forget to start prepping your club, crafting those upgrade SBCs, and saving your packs. TOTS is coming and it’s going to be massive.

We will share more updates on FC 25 in separate articles. If you found this information helpful or would like to learn more, please be sure to explore the other articles on our site.

Earning FC Points Efficiently: Tips and Tricks for EA SPORTS FC 25 Ultimate Team

FC 25 Team of the Season: How to Prepare for the Biggest Promo of the Year